Download Auditing and Ethics PDFs (pending)
Group 2 · Paper 5 · CA Intermediate
Select Answer to see a plan and any available model answer.
Question
An auditor checks a machinery payment in a bank statement and concludes the company owns the equipment. Identify the assertion gap and a better audit response.
Auditing and Ethics book purchase details
Name the assertion supported by the payment record and the separate assertion about ownership.
Explain why reliable evidence can still be irrelevant to the assertion being tested.
Choose primary rights evidence and state how you would match it to the specific machine.
Question
A material customer ignores a positive confirmation request. The finance team says silence confirms the amount. What should the auditor do?
Identify a non-response to a positive request under SA 505.
Name alternative procedures and link each to the receivable and reporting period.
Explain how a remaining evidence gap affects risk assessment or the report.
Silence is a non-response under SA 505 and does not confirm the receivable. Check that the original request was properly addressed and consider following up under the auditor’s control.
Perform alternative procedures directed at the actual balance. Match receipts after year-end to the specific customer and outstanding invoices, and examine invoices and dispatch or delivery records around year-end. Trace exceptions to the relevant account and period rather than assuming that any later receipt supports the entire balance.
Evaluate whether the alternatives provide enough appropriate evidence. If the positive confirmation is necessary or the alternatives leave a material uncertainty, reassess the risk and consider the implications for the audit opinion.
Question
An auditor picks entries from the inventory sheet and finds each on the warehouse floor. Which assertion does this support, and what test would address the opposite direction?
Auditing and Ethics book purchase details
Draw the two testing directions, from sheet to floor and from floor to sheet.
Name the assertion each direction supports.
Explain how you would select independent items in the second direction.
Question
A company reports very low trade payables at year-end. The auditor sees substantial payments in the ensuing month. Describe a targeted procedure.
State the risk that liabilities for goods or services received before year-end were omitted.
Start with payments after year-end and trace them back to receipt and invoice evidence.
Compare relevant dates and ledger entries and identify any required adjustment.
The main risk is an understatement of payables through incomplete recording or incorrect cut-off. Select material or otherwise relevant cash disbursements after year-end and trace them to supplier invoices, goods-received notes, or evidence of when services were performed.
For a pre-year-end receipt or service, check the year-end payable ledger and accrual schedule. If the obligation was present at year-end but absent from both, quantify the potential understatement and follow up with management. A later supplier invoice date does not by itself move the liability into the next period.
For later receipts, check that the expense and liability fall in the later period. Document the items tested and the exceptions found.
Question
A weekly exception report is signed, but staff say the report lists only invoices already approved. Is this control enough to detect unauthorised invoices?
Auditing and Ethics book purchase details
Describe the control objective before assessing the signed report.
Compare the population reviewed with the population that could contain unauthorised invoices.
Identify a completeness test and a control or substantive response to the uncovered risk.
Question
An audit file shows only a tick beside “price test” and no sample or conclusions. What would make the evidence reviewable under SA 230?
Use the SA 230 standard of what an experienced reviewer needs to understand the work.
List the tested items, procedure, results, exceptions and resulting conclusion.
Include performer and reviewer details and show how a tick would link to the evidence.
Under SA 230, the working paper should let an experienced auditor with no previous connection to the engagement understand the work performed, the evidence obtained and the conclusions reached. A standalone tick supplies none of the necessary context.
Record the objective and source of the price test, how the sample was selected, the identifying characteristics of each item tested and the agreed price evidence. Add the procedure performed, its timing and extent, the results, exceptions and how they were resolved.
Record who performed the work and when, and who reviewed it, the date and extent of review. Cross-reference supporting invoices or schedules so the conclusions can be traced to the actual test.
Question
A factory was operating normally at year-end. Six weeks later, a fire destroys a major production line. During the audit, what financial statement treatment should be assessed?
Auditing and Ethics book purchase details
Ask whether the fire gives evidence of a year-end condition or arose later.
Determine whether the event changes year-end amounts or calls for disclosure.
Evaluate materiality, continuity of operations and going concern separately.
Question
Management refuses to correct an inventory overstatement. The auditor has sufficient evidence and concludes the misstatement is material but not pervasive. Which opinion is appropriate?
Identify that the issue is a known misstatement supported by sufficient evidence.
Apply the materiality and pervasiveness tests separately.
State the resulting opinion and explain what the basis paragraph should communicate.
The auditor has evidence that inventory is overstated and management has declined to adjust it. The issue is therefore a detected misstatement. It is material but, on the auditor’s assessment in the question, its effects are not pervasive.
Under SA 705 (Revised), express a qualified opinion. In the Basis for Qualified Opinion section, describe the inventory overstatement and, where practicable, quantify its financial effects. The opinion explains that the statements are fairly presented subject to the effects of the matter described.
An adverse opinion would apply to a material and pervasive misstatement. A disclaimer concerns an inability to obtain evidence in circumstances where possible effects could be both material and pervasive.
Question
A company omits a low-value purchase directed by a director to a related party. The auditor’s quantitative threshold is much larger. Can the auditor dismiss the matter?
Auditing and Ethics book purchase details
Identify the related-party relationship and the disclosure risk.
Assess the governance implications as well as the small amount.
Check the applicable disclosure rules and explain the documented audit response.
Question
An audit firm helped prepare a client’s material impairment estimate. The audit team must now challenge the same estimate. What independence threat arises and how should it respond?
Identify the work the firm prepared and the judgment it must now audit.
Name the independence threat and check whether law and the applicable ethical rules permit the service.
State the action if the service is prohibited or the threat cannot be reduced to an acceptable level.
The firm would be auditing a material estimate it helped prepare. This is a self-review threat because the evidence and judgments underlying the estimate include the firm’s own previous work.
First check the relevant independence and statutory restrictions, including the nature of the service, any management responsibility assumed, and the client category. If the work is prohibited, the firm must not provide it. An internal review cannot override a prohibition.
Where the service is permitted, evaluate the threat in light of the estimate’s materiality and subjectivity. Apply effective safeguards where available, such as an appropriately independent review. If the threat remains unacceptable, decline or end the service or engagement as required.