Download Corporate and Other Laws PDFs (pending)
Group 1 · Paper 2 · CA Intermediate
Select Answer to see a plan and any available model answer.
Question
A new company closes its first financial year on 31 March. Its board proposes holding its first AGM the following February. Apply the Companies Act’s first-AGM rule.
Corporate and Other Laws book purchase details
Identify whether the case concerns a first AGM or a later AGM.
Count the first-AGM period from the close of the first financial year.
Compare the proposed month with the deadline and address the Registrar’s extension power.
Question
A company publishes a social-media advertisement inviting anyone to subscribe to its proposed private placement. It plans to make offers only to applicants it later selects. Can it advertise this way?
Identify section 42 as the applicable route and separate offer recipients from advertising channels.
Apply the rule to who can see and respond to the post.
Conclude whether screening afterwards cures the public invitation and state the proper route.
Section 42 permits a private placement to identified persons through the prescribed process. It also restricts use of public advertising and public-facing distribution or marketing channels to inform the public at large about the issue.
Here, the social-media post invites anyone to subscribe. The company has already approached the public at large when it posts the invitation. Later shortlisting restricts the final recipients, but does not reverse the earlier public solicitation.
The company cannot advertise the placement in this way. It should identify eligible offerees before communicating the offer and follow the private-placement procedure, including the applicable approvals and prescribed offer documents.
Question
A company received application money for a private placement and could not allot within 60 days. It proposes keeping the money until day 90. What does section 42 require?
Corporate and Other Laws book purchase details
Draw a timeline starting on receipt of application money.
Mark the allotment deadline and the following repayment window separately.
If both are missed, identify the statutory interest rate and the date from which it runs.
Question
A company calls an AGM with only 10 clear days’ notice. Members entitled to vote representing 93% of the members by number consent. Is that enough for a shorter-notice AGM?
Start with the ordinary notice period and name the meeting as an AGM.
State the shorter-notice consent test and show whether 93% meets it.
Conclude on the proposed date and the valid ways to proceed.
Under section 101 of the Companies Act, the ordinary general-meeting notice period is at least 21 clear days. An AGM can be convened on shorter notice if the required members consent in writing or electronically. For an AGM the threshold is at least 95% of members entitled to vote at the meeting.
The company has given 10 clear days. Only 93% of eligible members by number consent, leaving a shortfall of two percentage points. The threshold is measured against eligible members, rather than only the people who happen to attend.
The AGM cannot rely on the shorter-notice route on these facts. Obtain the required consent or convene the meeting with the ordinary statutory notice.
Question
A private company’s articles do not require a larger quorum. One member attends in person and two other members send proxies. Can the meeting proceed on that attendance?
Corporate and Other Laws book purchase details
State the statutory quorum rule for a private company and read the qualification about its articles.
Count the members personally present separately from ordinary proxies.
Compare that count with the default quorum and conclude on the meeting.
Question
The board recommends ₹4 per share as final dividend. Assume the company follows Table F on dividend declarations. At the general meeting, members propose ₹6 per share. Can they declare it?
Identify who recommends the final dividend and who declares it under Table F.
Treat the board’s figure as the ceiling for the members’ resolution.
Apply the ceiling to ₹6 and state the maximum possible on the stated recommendation.
Under the assumed Table F articles, the board recommends the amount of final dividend and the company in general meeting may declare it. The members’ power to declare the amount operates within the recommendation, which sets the maximum for the resolution.
The board has recommended ₹4 per share. A declaration of ₹6 per share would exceed that recommendation by ₹2 per share. The general meeting can declare up to ₹4 under the existing recommendation, provided the dividend also meets the applicable statutory requirements.
An increase would require a revised recommendation and compliance with the applicable process. Members cannot create a higher ceiling by voting for the proposed ₹6 amount alone.
Question
The board wants to remove a serving statutory auditor mid-term and replace the auditor at the next general meeting. Is an ordinary shareholder resolution enough?
Corporate and Other Laws book purchase details
Distinguish removal during an auditor’s term from ordinary appointment or retirement.
List the approval and voting requirements in their correct order.
Include the auditor’s opportunity to be heard before concluding.
Question
A company has no current operating profit. Its manager suggests using the gain from revaluing its building to justify a dividend. Explain why that is a poor basis.
Identify the proposed source of dividend and the limit in section 123.
Classify the building’s valuation uplift as realised or unrealised and explain the result.
Consider a separate lawful source only if the conditions for using it are met.
Section 123 regulates the sources from which a dividend can be declared. In determining distributable profits, exclude unrealised gains arising from a revaluation. Raising the book value of a building creates an accounting uplift without realising that gain through a disposal or other transaction.
The manager therefore cannot use this revaluation gain to support a dividend. The absence of current operating profit is a separate point. Eligible undistributed profits of earlier years, after the applicable depreciation requirement, or a permitted draw from free reserves may be considered if the statutory and prescribed conditions are satisfied.
On the stated facts, the suggested revaluation gain provides no lawful basis for the declaration.
Question
An enactment is repealed. A liability arose under it before repeal, and the replacement law expresses no contrary intention. Is the old liability automatically extinguished?
Corporate and Other Laws book purchase details
Locate when the liability arose relative to repeal.
Apply the General Clauses Act savings rule and search the replacement law for a contrary intention.
Address separately whether the liability and proceedings to enforce it survive.
Question
A statute says a licensing authority “may” provide a hearing before making an order. The public body argues the word alone always makes a hearing optional. How should a student analyse this?
Start with the ordinary discretionary reading of “may”.
Identify the purpose of a prior hearing, the effect of the order and related procedural provisions.
Compare both readings and give a conditional conclusion supported by the scheme.
The word “may” commonly confers discretion, so that is the starting point. Its effect must still be read in the context of the whole enactment. Here the important issues are what the licensing order does, whose interests it affects, and whether the hearing safeguards those interests before the authority acts.
Read the surrounding provisions for exceptions, procedural safeguards and remedies. If the statute entrusts the power to protect affected parties and treating a hearing as optional would defeat that protection, the context can support a mandatory duty. If the wider scheme permits the authority to dispense with a hearing in specified circumstances, those provisions shape the answer.
The word alone does not settle the dispute. State which interpretation follows from the statutory purpose and available context.